Mubarak in a Cage

Al-Akhbar is currently going through a transitional phase whereby the English website is available for Archival purposes only. All new content will be published in Arabic on the main website (

Al-Akhbar Management

The sight of Mubarak in a cage was historical. Arabs saw Saddam behind bars, but they were not impressed. Contrary to the wishful thinking of American neo-conservatives and liberals, the entire Iraqi political process under occupation never impressed Arabs. It was all part of a US-orchestrated charade. The spectacle of humiliating Arab rulers is not new. Arab leaders have been mistreated, shot at, and executed. Decades ago, Colonel Amin Hafez of Syria had to call on his family to help him in a shoot-out with armed men outside his home, while Abdul-Karim Qasim’s rule in Iraq ended in a small room.

What is significant today about the sight of Mubarak is that he finally got to see the extent to which most Egyptians hated him. Arab potentates are always shielded by their vast entourage and court jesters from the extent of public antipathy to their persons. In Syria, demonstrators have held signs informing Bashar “We don’t like you.” This must not be easy for Arab tyrants to stomach. They — especially the younger generation of the successors — have been raised on the myth of public love for them. Mubarak had to believe that he was loved so he could take the Egyptian people for granted, as well as offend and violate public wishes in their name. Saudi Arabia and the GCC tyrants interceded to prevent the appearance of Mubarak behind bars. They knew that it would constitute an important precedent. Arab potentates are very obsessive about their magisterial and imperial postures and images. They are not prone to show weaknesses in public. They are keen on projecting a semi-divine image of themselves. This explains why Mubarak wanted to prosecute anyone who hinted that he may have suffered from ill health. Yet, as soon as he was deposed, ill health became his excuse and his shield.

The charade of the court, arranged by the Military Council to thwart justice rather than achieve it, should not continue. The Council wanted to give something superficial to the public, and the image was good enough. There was no reason to allow Mubarak, with his hair still dyed and coiffed, to appear on a stretcher. This was intended to garner sympathy for him in order to end the court proceedings. When that did not happen, TV transmission stopped. A real trial for Mubarak would, by definition, bring into focus the disgraceful roles of all the members of the Military Council who were handpicked by Mubarak. The Mubarak trial may not produce the desired results: events in Egypt are moving fast and the Egyptian Military Council’s precarious hold on power may not last. The revolutionary momentum may reach the doorsteps of the top generals.

But the psychological symbolism of Mubarak in a cage should not be underestimated: if there is one phrase that captures the spirit of the so-called “Arab Spring” (the name is a misnomer because rivers of blood are flowing in the course of this “spring”; as Iraqi poet Badr Shakir al-Sayyab once observed in a poem, “Agents of Qasim are firing, Oh, for the Spring”), it is the “loss of fear.” Arab potentates are not awesome or intimidating. Even amid the pomp of royalty in the Gulf, rulers are forced to appease their population and deflect popular resentment by buying themselves out of the crisis, but they still have to do something. Mubarak will die in police custody while his two sons lose their privileges. All three will die with the full knowledge that they were all hated during a protracted era of oppression.


Asad AbuKhalil rules and is one of the greatest opponents of Zionist racism around the globe. Great to see a column here in English. Very positive.

Great post. Thank you As'ad and congrats Al-Akhbar. I join my voice to 'falastin' and say: finally a great source of news in English.
Start spreading the news.

Despite of the real demands of arab citizens, they have not shown any of right way to lead a revolution literally, but we still hope a new face of arab world according to what is happening in the region. It is not a revolution until it cancels camp David's treaty, it is not a revolution until it cancels the iron hand of the Military Council. A real revolution is of the citizen themselves upon themselves, toward a new enlightenment of practicing human rights and knowing exactly what democracy means. I mean holding a sight of not letting any single political pattern to control the political, economical and social atmosphere on behalf the whole people.

A wonderful first post! Please keep them coming! Your analysis is always insightful and candid and now we can find it regularly here.... Fantastic! Congratulations to Al-Akhbar too .... We have been waiting for an English version. I am thrilled!

Loving the new site!

Watch this video to understand what Egyptiens thought about the Mubarak's court instead of hearing cliches over and over:

A good read, like usual.
Congradulations, Al-akhbar.
A facebook and twitter link to this article is much needed

mabrouk (Congratulations) the website!!

Nice post.

Right now there is a power vacuum in Egypt (that the military is trying to control). I don’t have the slightest idea as to what this may lead to, hopefully, if the ‘’spring’’, ‘’Arab uprising’’, or ‘’revolution’’ is to be considered a force for positive change, some form of democratic institutions will begin to appear.

The first step -- that of ripping oneself from the yoke of the tyrant’s oppression – is a good step. But now the revolution, or whatever you want to call it, has to go through a process under which a democratic system can emerge.

The military has proven itself to be opposed to democracy; so hopefully power can be removed from them and into the hands of the people.

I must admit that seeing Mubarak in a cage was an oddity. One can only imagine the emotions he is swimming through. One day he is the man who ‘’keeps the region stable’’ (as Obama put it), to a man on his death bed and locked in a cage.

On a side note, I’m very happy to finally see this paper up in English. I hope it proves as successful in English as it does in Arabic.

What a relief, finally, English readers have an alternative to Al Jazeera English.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd><img><h1><h2><h3><h4><h5><h6><blockquote><span><aside>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

^ Back to Top