Opposition figure criticizes SNC ties to Syrian rebels

Al-Akhbar is currently going through a transitional phase whereby the English website is available for Archival purposes only. All new content will be published in Arabic on the main website (www.al-akhbar.com).

Al-Akhbar Management

Published Friday, January 13, 2012

Opposition figure, Haytham al-Manna, criticized on Friday the Syrian National Council's (SNC) decision to deepen its relations with army defectors waging an armed insurrection against the regime.

The SNC announced in a press release on Thursday that it aimed to "improve cooperation [with the Free Syrian Army] in the political and relief arenas."

SNC head Burhan Ghalioun met with Free Syrian Army (FSA) chief Riad Al-Asa’ad and his deputy Malek Kurdi to thrash out means to "increase the level of coordination and activate mechanisms of communications" between the two groups.

"The SNC proposed a plan of action concerning mechanisms and avenues of support to be offered to pro-revolution sectors of the Syrian military," the statement read.

"The parties agreed to formulate a detailed plan, to include the reorganization of FSA units and brigades, and the creation of a format to accommodate within FSA ranks additional officers and soldiers, especially senior military officials, who side with the revolution."

The two organizations also "intend to establish a liaison office... in order to maintain direct communications around the clock."

The SNC – an umbrella organization that includes the Muslim Brotherhood as well as secular activists – formerly opposed the use of military force against the regime, releasing a political program in November that stressed the "peaceful nature" of the revolution.

Ghalioun had also previously urged the FSA to refrain from offensive attacks and remain a defensive force, which appeared to have no effect on the rebels' actions.

Closer ties between the two organizations – both of which are based in Turkey – might be interpreted as an attempt by the SNC to increase its influence over the rebels.

Manna of the National Coordination Body for Democratic Change in Syria (NCB) opposed enhancing the FSA's role in the struggle against Assad, accusing the armed rebels of serving Turkish interests.

"We know that the Turkish government plays an important role in the political decisions of the Free Syrian Army," he told Al-Akhbar.

"We don't believe that an armed group can be on Turkish territory and remain independent of Turkish decisions."

The NCB is a separate umbrella opposition organization that includes predominantly secular leftists, human rights activists and nationalists, and staunchly opposes foreign interference in the Syrian uprising, while insisting on a pacifist revolution.

"The militarization of the Syrian revolution signifies the death of the internal revolution," Manna said, referring to the FSA's armed insurrection against the regime.

"We don't have an example where an armed struggle against a dictatorial regime won."

The NCB official stressed that his organization is independent of foreign interests, and adamant on the peaceful nature of the revolution.

Manna queried the FSA's absolute loyalty to the aims of the revolution, adding that the rebels included non-Syrian elements, as well as Salafists.

"We know that there are more volunteers than defectors [in the FSA], we know that there are non-Syrians along with Syrians. This doesn't encourage us because we know today that the volunteers include Salafists, the worst of the extremists in the Arab world."

"We don't believe the Free Syrian Army is a project that can help the Syrian revolution."

Manna rebutted SNC claims that the FSA can play a vital role in protecting unarmed protesters from regime attacks, pointing to local organized committees formed to assist demonstrators.

"In certain regions such as Daraa, it's the population that protects the defectors."

The opposition figure raised fears of a rising death toll should the FSA subsume the peaceful revolution into a violent struggle.

"The problem is when we have an armed uprising, the number of deaths will increase," Manna said.

"Our goal is to protect the Syrians, to save the lives, not to increase the death toll," he said, noting a key difference with the SNC that have sought to include the FSA within the revolution.

An agreement signed in Cairo between Manna and the SNC's Ghalioun late December appears to have collapsed, with the two political opposition groups diverging on a number of points, most notably the FSA and the use of arms in the revolution.

Western powers have called on Syria's divided opposition to sort out their differences, but the SNC's move for closer ties with the armed rebels has driven a wider wedge with the core pacifists in the revolution.

Manna acknowledged that "there's a lot of differences between us (NCB) and the SNC, and not uniquely concerning the FSA," but said the door remains open for cooperation.

"There will always be means to coordinate on one level or another with all organizations that are against the Syrian regime; for a transition to democracy; and for a pacifist approach."

The SNC did not respond to requests for comment before this story was published.



Given SNC open calls for Libya-style foreign intervention, it is rich to hear from "anti-violence" and anti-foreign intervention Manna that "There will always be means to coordinate on one level or another with all organizations that are against the Syrian regime; for a transition to democracy; and for a pacifist approach." Given that organizations that are against the Syrian regime include NATO and GCC, I suppose Manna is for some "pacifist" bombing by NATO. Of course, Saudi royals are all "for a transition to democracy", their help would be key to Manna's goals.

The good news from this very dishonest words: it seems that Manna at least admits that Syrians are NOT eager supporters for repeating Libya's rape of their country under pretext of "revolution". I suppose Manna knows that murders by so-called FSA are NOT welcome even to foes of Assad regime. Of course, if NATO/Saudis decide to "liberate" Syria with FSA as pawns, they would NOT give a damn for Manna's not-so honest protests.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd><img><h1><h2><h3><h4><h5><h6><blockquote><span><aside>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

^ Back to Top